Bioethics’ Duty to Meet in Qatar: Reply to Magnus: Reply to Magnus

Is it unethical to host an international bioethics conference in Qatar? In an editorial in this issue, David Magnus (Citation2024) argues that conferencing in Qatar, or other places where human rights violations occur, is not ethically justified. According to Magnus, the International Association of Bioethics’ (IABs’) decision to host the 2024 World Congress of Bioethics (WCB) at a Qatari-based university was “a major mistake by the IAB board.”

We hold a much different view. In the face of unjust laws and human rights violations, more than one response is ethically defensible – as some of us have argued (Jecker and Ravitsky Citation2023; Jecker et al. Citation2024a; Jecker et al. Citation2024b; Jecker, Verweij, et al. Citation2023; Ghaly, El Akoum, and Afdhal Citation2023). Boycotting is one way to seek to change an unjust situation, but so too is engaging with people who are willing to host, hear, and take seriously challenges and objections to their prevailing norms (Jecker, Ravitsky, et al. Citation2023). Qatari-based hosts have invited bioethicists from around the world to engage with them in an open exchange of ideas, and offered a conference venue where this can occur. Bioethicists should engage, and should foster open and respectful dialogue.

To avoid redundancy with arguments some of us have developed elsewhere (Jecker and Ravitsky Citation2023; Jecker et al. Citation2024a; Jecker et al. Citation2024b; Jecker, Verweij, et al. Citation2023; Ghaly, El Akoum, and Afdhal Citation2023), we limit our response mostly to points not considered previously.